Not even the Order of Saint John was immune to quarrelling and intrigues. In 1528, the Zurich authorities succeeded in imposing the new Protestant faith through an intentionally wrongful arrest at the Bubikon Commandery.
Stefanie Fivian is a historian and a member of staff at the Stapferhaus.
The 1520s were a turbulent time for the city and region of Zurich, especially with regard to theological issues, which in many instances were linked to exercising or maintaining influence and power. For a long time, the authorities in Zurich had been trying to extend their area of influence and profit financially by astutely meddling in legal affairs outside their own territorial remit. This was what happened at an establishment of the Order of Saint John, the Bubikon Commandery – a medieval monastery of the Knights Hospitaller – located in the Zurich Oberland. In 1525 a new administrator, Heinrich Felder, was appointed to the Commandery and the Zurich authorities tried to get him, by way of a bogus vow when he was sworn in, to pay them higher taxes than had been agreed with the head of the Order. Felder was having none of it. He saw his role as that of agent of the head of the Order, and he was devoted to the old Catholic faith. He had little time for the new theological ideas of his age, and frequently expressed his anger about the new religious views.So it’s hardly surprising that several years later, in early January 1528, the Zurich Council asked Felder to attend the Bern Disputation, where representatives of the new faith and adherents of the old were to meet and discuss some ambiguous points of denominational practice. Felder was expected to offer his apologies for his ideological disobedience – in other words, for remaining faithful to the old orthodox Catholic beliefs – and to publicly undertake a kind of “tuition” in the matter of correct faith. But the Bubikon Schaffner (steward) showed himself to be recalcitrant, replying to the letter from Zurich that he was unable to understand the allegations made by the mayor and the council. He had always behaved as a loyal citizen and if the people of Zurich thought otherwise, they should contact the head of the Order of Saint John – a clear message that they had no say in matters pertaining to the Commandery.The authorities in Zurich weren’t slow to respond to this affront. Almost immediately, they accused the commander of having unlawfully removed certain items of Commandery property from the church and taken them to the Orthodox Catholic community in Rapperswil. For this crime Felder was, without further ado, imprisoned in the Wellenberg at the end of February 1528. During the subsequent investigation, Felder’s persecutors sought grounds to enable them to dismiss the objectionable steward from his post, but the three witnesses mostly reported on Felder’s dissolute and immoral lifestyle.
All three stated that Felder had a taste for alcohol and also encouraged other people to drink excessively. One witness even talked about a boozy session in Rapperswil, where Felder himself continued to pour more alcohol into people who were already completely intoxicated, and then left them for the menials to deal with. The second witness also claimed that when asked why he didn’t want to go to the Bern Disputation, Felder allegedly said “he shit on the Disputation”. The third stated that Felder had thrown a measuring jug at him during a heated discussion. All three thus painted a picture of a thoroughly dishonourable man, just as the Zurich authorities would have wanted; the actual allegation of the stolen Commandery property obviously was not really the focus of the investigation.One of the witnesses was Johannes Stumpf, today known in particular as a chronicler, although at the time he played a key role as Prior of Bubikon. But instead of covering his own steward’s back, as in other Commanderies, it was in fact he who came forward again after the first witness testimonies because he had thought of more bad things about Felder that he wished to put on record. There had been bad blood between the two ever since Stumpf converted to Protestantism – despite his position as an orthodox Catholic prior in the service of the Order of Saint John. Stumpf continued to do everything in his power to oppose Felder, who stood in the way of the Reformation finally taking hold in the Commandery.Only two of the witnesses commented on the question of the stolen goods, and their statements were brief. Laurentz Appenzeller, who was close to the Commander, testified that in the past he had been to the Schultheiss and council of Rapperswil, probably on behalf of the steward, and had taken a number of items to them for safe-keeping. This statement was supplemented by a further statement from Stumpf, who claimed that at the time of the rioting in Wädenswil, Felder had brought a number of letters, a Jahrzeitbuch (book of church records) and other things to Rapperswil.This is a crucial piece of information, because the Wädenswil riots can be dated to around 1523-24 – several years before Felder’s arrest in February 1528. In his written defence, Felder himself asserted that these actions had taken place years before his arrest, and with the knowledge and consent of the authorities in Zurich. During the Wädenswil riots, fearing rampaging and looting by the rebellious subjects, he had taken the items to a place of safety, and had informed both the head of the Order of Saint John and the Zurich authorities that he had done so. The mayor of Wädenswil, Walder, who had been in office since 1524, had told him personally that he could leave the items in Rapperswil. This seems to have been true because, interestingly, shortly thereafter Felder was convicted not for the removal of the Commandery’s property, but for the throwing of the jug at one of the witnesses and for the excessive drinking in Rapperswil – both things that had not been reported earlier. The ostensible reason for Felder’s arrest was thus simply an excuse.The fact that the Zurich authorities sent their own people to the Commandery immediately following the arrest and imposed the new Protestant faith with immediate effect suggests, just like the verdict, that their intention all along was to push Felder out of office because of his religious convictions, by whatever means necessary. Ultimately, despite repeated protests the Order of Saint John had nothing with which to oppose Zurich’s actions – and a new era dawned.
On 9 June 1712, Christoph Lieber lost his head. A prominent Catholic Klostervogt (abbey bailiff), Lieber was one of the reasons why the conflict between the Swiss denominations flared up again at the beginning of the 18th century.
On 26 June 1529, the First Peace of Kappel was agreed. Catholics and Protestants laid down their arms at the last minute and ate soup together. But the peace didn’t last long. Two years later, the parties were facing off against each other yet again.